Pauta conformance

Pauta is the set of guidelines Editora and its sibling apps follow, so they look and work the same on Windows, macOS and Linux. Each rule has an ID and a level: a MUST is required, a SHOULD is expected unless there is a stated reason.

Editora is working toward Pauta 6.0.1.

Pauta conformance: Partial. Editora does not meet every MUST of this edition yet: 16 are pending.

ConformanceMeans
CompleteEvery MUST and every SHOULD is met, does not apply, or is a recorded deviation.
CoreEvery MUST is met; one or more SHOULDs are still pending.
PartialOne or more MUSTs are still pending. The app says Working toward, not Built to.

The conformance is worked out from the list below, never typed in, so it cannot claim more than the list shows. The same list is in the app: Help → Pauta Conformance opens it, and About names the edition and the conformance.

Pending

Rules Editora does not meet yet. Each one links the issue that tracks it. 32 rules: 16 MUST, 16 SHOULD.

RuleLevelWhat is differentLink
ABOUT-01MUSTOn macOS, About Editora is in the Help menu rather than the application menu.#1574
CLI-07MUSTA launch with —disable-plugins starts a second Editora instead of handing over to the one already running.#1570
CLI-11MUSTOn Windows there is no console launcher, so command-line output does not appear in the terminal that started Editora.#1570
DOCS-05MUSTThe notes on a GitHub release are a list of commits rather than notes written for users.#1557
ICON-16MUSTThere is no theme that follows the system’s light or dark setting.#1563
MENU-14MUSTSome menu rows have no icon.#1566
PAUTA-13MUSTThe user guide on the website has no page yet that lists this conformance and these exceptions.#1554
REL-16MUSTThe runnable jar downloads for Linux are not signed like the other Linux downloads.#1578
REL-29MUSTBefore a release, only the macOS build is started as packaged to confirm it launches.#1578
SET-06MUSTEvery setting has a command in the Command Palette except the terminal’s multi-line paste confirmation, which should be turned off only in the config file, and so should lose its Settings row rather than gain a command.#1568
SET-13MUSTOn a machine with no system keychain, AI API keys are kept in the settings file.#1568
SET-16MUSTWhether plugins need a signed registry can be turned off from Settings and the Command Palette.#1568
TABS-13MUSTThe Terminal command gives an open terminal the keyboard before it hides it, so its stripe button does not run it, and the File Information and External Tools commands are not named after their windows.#1565
TBAR-03MUSTSome buttons keep words of their own where they say more than their command’s title, such as Maximize or Restore on a tool window’s header.#1564
WIN-03MUSTOn Windows and Linux the menu bar sits below the title bar unless you turn on the extended window setting.#1562
WIN-13MUSTQuitting from the macOS menu or Dock closes each window in turn instead of going through Editora’s own Quit.#1562
ACC-07SHOULDThe release steps do not include a pass with a screen reader.#1561
ACC-09SHOULDThere is no high-contrast theme, and the high-contrast setting of Windows is not followed.#1561
CONF-07SHOULDEditora asks before a few actions that can be undone, such as moving a file to the trash.#1575
CONF-11SHOULDThe Force Push command can be run directly, without a rejected push first.#1575
DOCS-04SHOULDThe website does not check on every build that its generated pages still match the app.#1557
DOCS-18SHOULDScreenshots for the website are not taken by a built-in capture at double resolution.#1557
PAUTA-14SHOULDThe website’s conformance page is not generated from Editora’s own list of exceptions yet.#1554
PLAT-14SHOULDThe snippets file is edited as text, to keep your comments, rather than read into typed data.#1555
REL-04SHOULDRelease notes are not taken from the changelog.#1578
REL-09SHOULDThe Linux app ID is com.editora.Editora rather than one under io.github.#1578
REL-12SHOULDEditora cannot be installed with Homebrew yet.#1578
REL-13SHOULDEditora cannot be installed with winget yet.#1578
REL-14SHOULDNo access token for publishing to package managers is set up, since none is used yet.#1578
REL-17SHOULDThe Windows installer is not signed.#1578
REL-25SHOULDA few automated build steps download Maven’s dependencies again instead of reusing a cache.#1578
WIN-15SHOULDOn macOS, Settings is not in the application menu.#1562